Peer Review Process

Editorial Assessment

Every submission is first assessed by the Editor-in-Chief or a designated editor. The initial assessment considers scope, originality, scholarly importance, methodological appropriateness, ethical compliance, presentation, and adherence to the author guidelines. The journal may return a submission for technical corrections, request additional information, or decline it without external review if it is unsuitable or does not meet the journal’s standards.

Peer Review Process

Elevate uses a double-anonymized peer-review process for Original Research Articles, Review Articles, and Case Reports. The identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another. Manuscripts that pass editorial assessment are normally evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant subject and methodological expertise. Editorials may be assessed by the Editor-in-Chief and may be sent for external review when appropriate.

Reviewers are asked to assess the originality, relevance, methodological rigor, ethical aspects, clarity of reporting, interpretation of findings, and contribution of the manuscript. Reviewers provide recommendations to the handling editor; the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor makes the final decision.

Editorial Decisions

  • Accept: the manuscript is accepted for publication, subject to any required production or technical checks.
  • Minor revision: limited changes are required before a further editorial decision.
  • Major revision: substantial changes are required; resubmission does not guarantee acceptance.
  • Reject: the manuscript is not suitable for publication in Elevate.

Revised manuscripts should be accompanied by a point-by-point response to all reviewer and editor comments. Authors should indicate where changes have been made and provide a reasoned explanation where a suggestion has not been followed. The revised manuscript should clearly identify changes, unless otherwise instructed.

Reviewer Selection and Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers are selected based on relevant expertise, publication record, methodological knowledge, and absence of competing interests. Authors may suggest potential reviewers, but the journal is not obliged to use them. Reviewers must disclose any conflict of interest and decline the invitation if they cannot provide an impartial assessment.

Editorial Independence and Editor Submissions

Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, relevance, originality, methodological quality, and compliance with ethical standards. Decisions must not be influenced by commercial, financial, institutional, or personal interests. If the Editor-in-Chief, an editor, or an editorial board member submits a manuscript, that person must not participate in its editorial handling, reviewer selection, or decision-making. The manuscript must be managed by an independent editor and undergo the journal’s usual review standards.

Appeals and Complaints

Authors may submit a reasoned appeal when they believe that an editorial decision involved a material factual misunderstanding, a significant procedural error, or an apparent breach of editorial policy. Appeals should include the manuscript reference number, the decision being appealed, and a concise explanation supported by relevant evidence. Disagreement with a reviewer’s academic opinion alone is not normally sufficient grounds for appeal.

Complaints about editorial conduct, peer review, publication ethics, or journal procedures should be submitted in writing to the Editorial Office. Where the complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief, it should be referred to an appropriate independent representative of the journal’s publisher or governing institution. Appeals and complaints will be handled fairly and confidentially.

Publication Frequency and Online Publication

Elevate is published twice a year. Accepted articles may undergo copyediting, typesetting, and author proof review before publication. Authors are responsible for checking proofs carefully and returning corrections within the specified timeframe. Substantive changes to the scientific content are not normally permitted at the proof stage without editorial approval. Published articles are assigned a DOI when the journal’s DOI registration process is completed.