Plagiarism and Retraction
Plagiarism, Similarity, and Redundant Publication Policy
The Editorial Board of Elevate is committed to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics and academic integrity. Plagiarism, including the inappropriate use of previously published material, is considered a serious breach of publication ethics and will not be tolerated. This policy outlines the procedures and potential actions that may be taken when plagiarism or other forms of inappropriate textual or conceptual overlap are identified in manuscripts submitted to or published in Elevate.
Elevate uses plagiarism-detection software, such as Turnitin, to assist the editorial team in identifying textual similarities between submitted manuscripts and previously published works. Similarity reports are assessed by the editors in context. A similarity score alone does not constitute evidence of plagiarism; the nature, extent, and source of the overlap are considered in the editorial assessment.
1. Definition of Plagiarism
Plagiarism is the use of another person's ideas, words, data, research findings, or other intellectual contributions without appropriate acknowledgment, presenting them as one's own original work. It includes direct copying, close paraphrasing without proper attribution, and the unauthorized use or reproduction of another author's intellectual work.
Plagiarism may also involve the inappropriate reuse of an author's own previously published work without proper acknowledgment, commonly referred to as self-plagiarism or redundant publication.
2. General Policy
All manuscripts submitted to Elevate must represent original scholarly work and must not have been published previously or be under consideration for publication by another journal.
Authors are required to acknowledge all sources appropriately. Any material reproduced verbatim from another source must be clearly distinguished from the authors' own writing, for example, through quotation marks or block quotations, and accompanied by an appropriate citation.
The reproduction of substantial portions of text, tables, figures, images, or other copyrighted material from previously published works requires appropriate permission from the copyright holder, in addition to proper acknowledgment of the original source. Authors are responsible for obtaining and documenting such permissions before publication.
The editorial team evaluates suspected plagiarism on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the extent of overlap, the originality of the material, the significance of the duplicated content, and whether appropriate citations and permissions have been provided.
3. Levels of Plagiarism and Editorial Actions
When plagiarism is suspected or identified, the Editor-in-Chief, in consultation with the relevant handling editor and, where necessary, the Editorial Board, will determine the appropriate action based on the severity of the case.
The following categories provide guidance for editorial decisions.
3.1 Minor Plagiarism
Definition: A limited portion of text has been reproduced or closely paraphrased from another source without appropriate acknowledgment, without involving substantial data, research findings, or original ideas.
Editorial action: The authors will receive a formal warning and be requested to revise the relevant sections, provide appropriate citations, and ensure that the manuscript complies with the journal's originality requirements. The revised manuscript may be reassessed before further consideration.
3.2 Moderate Plagiarism
Definition: A substantial portion of the manuscript contains text, ideas, or other intellectual material taken from another publication without adequate acknowledgment, but the case does not involve the deliberate reproduction of the original study's principal findings or contributions.
Editorial action: The manuscript will normally be rejected. Depending on the seriousness of the case and the available evidence, the authors may be prohibited from submitting manuscripts to Elevate for a period of up to one year.
3.3 Severe Plagiarism
Definition: Extensive plagiarism involving the reproduction of substantial portions of another publication, including its original data, research findings, central arguments, or intellectual contributions, without appropriate acknowledgment or permission.
Editorial action: The manuscript will be rejected. The authors may be prohibited from submitting manuscripts to Elevate for a period of up to five years. If the misconduct involves a published article, further action, including retraction, may be considered.
All authors listed on a manuscript are collectively responsible for ensuring the integrity and originality of the submitted work. Where a plagiarism-related sanction is imposed, the Editorial Board may apply the relevant action to all listed authors, taking into account their respective responsibilities and involvement.
In cases involving repeated plagiarism by the same author or authors, the Editorial Board, under the direction of the Editor-in-Chief, may impose more stringent sanctions, including a permanent prohibition on future submissions to Elevate.
4. Self-Plagiarism and Redundant Publication
This policy also applies to the reuse of material previously published by the same author or authors. Authors must clearly identify and cite any previously published text, figures, tables, data, or other material incorporated into a new manuscript.
The submission of a manuscript containing substantial overlap with another manuscript submitted to a different journal, whether simultaneously or subsequently, may constitute redundant or duplicate publication. Authors must not submit the same manuscript, or substantially similar versions of the same work, to more than one journal at the same time.
For editorial assessment, the following criteria may be considered when evaluating self-plagiarism or redundant publication:
- Severe overlap: Substantial duplication involving approximately one-half or more of the manuscript, particularly where identical or nearly identical figures, tables, data, or substantial portions of text are reproduced. Such cases may be treated as severe misconduct.
- Moderate overlap: Reuse involving more than one-tenth but less than one-half of the manuscript, without adequate acknowledgment or justification. Such cases may be treated as moderate misconduct.
- Limited methodological overlap: Reuse confined primarily to the Methods section may be considered a minor concern, provided that the reuse is appropriately acknowledged and does not misrepresent the originality of the current study.
These proportions serve as indicative criteria rather than automatic thresholds. The Editorial Board will consider the context, nature, and significance of the duplicated material when determining the appropriate action.
If substantial overlap is identified between a manuscript submitted to Elevate and a manuscript submitted to or published in another journal, the Editor-in-Chief may contact the editor of the other journal to clarify the circumstances. Where duplicate publication or serious publication misconduct is established, the case will be handled in accordance with the relevant provisions of this policy.
5. Reuse of Previously Published Material
Authors may refer to or reuse their previously published material when necessary to explain the background, methodology, or development of new research. However, such material must be appropriately cited, and the authors must clearly explain the contribution and novelty of the current manuscript in relation to their previous publications.
Where previously published text, tables, figures, or other copyrighted materials are reproduced, authors must obtain permission from the relevant copyright holder and provide appropriate acknowledgment.
Manuscripts developed from conference presentations or proceedings may be considered for publication provided that the authors:
- Clearly disclose the previous conference presentation or publication.
- Provide the title, name, and publication date of the conference proceedings, where applicable.
- Demonstrate that the submitted manuscript contains sufficient original scholarly contribution beyond the previously disseminated material.
- Obtain permission from the copyright holder when required.
The final decision on whether such manuscripts are eligible for publication rests with the Editor-in-Chief.
Material presented previously in an unpublished conference presentation, including oral presentations and visual materials, may be incorporated into a subsequent journal manuscript, provided that it does not violate third-party copyright or other applicable rights.
Manuscripts that have previously been published in another language must disclose the details of the original publication, including its title, publication date, and journal. Such submissions will be evaluated by the Editor-in-Chief to determine whether republication is appropriate, whether the necessary copyright permissions have been obtained, and whether the proposed publication offers a clear scholarly justification. The journal reserves the right to decline such submissions.
In exceptional circumstances, Elevate may consider the republication of a previously published article for scholarly or educational purposes. Any such republication must be transparently identified, with full details of the original publication and appropriate permission from the author(s) and copyright holder.
6. Editorial Handling of Suspected Plagiarism
When potential plagiarism or redundant publication is identified, the Editor-in-Chief will assess the available evidence and determine the appropriate course of action. Authors may be contacted and invited to provide an explanation or clarification.
Depending on the findings, editorial actions may include:
- Requesting clarification or a revised manuscript;
- Issuing a formal warning;
- Rejecting the submitted manuscript;
- Restricting the authors' eligibility to submit future manuscripts for a specified period;
- Notifying relevant institutions or other journal editors, where appropriate; and
- Initiating post-publication action, including correction or retraction, when necessary.
The Editorial Board will maintain appropriate records of confirmed cases and any sanctions imposed. These records may be consulted when evaluating subsequent submissions from the same authors, while ensuring that editorial decisions are made fairly and consistently.
7. Retraction Policy
Articles published in Elevate may be considered for retraction when there is clear evidence of serious publication misconduct or when the reliability or integrity of the published work is substantially compromised.
Grounds for retraction may include, but are not limited to:
- Clear evidence that the findings are unreliable as a result of research misconduct, such as data fabrication or falsification, or a significant honest error, including miscalculation or methodological error.
- Evidence that the findings have been published previously elsewhere without appropriate acknowledgment, cross-referencing, permission, or justification.
- Evidence of plagiarism involving substantial portions of another work.
- Evidence that the research was conducted or reported in violation of applicable ethical standards.
- Other circumstances in which the integrity or reliability of the published article is seriously compromised.
Retraction decisions will be made by the Editor-in-Chief in consultation with the Editorial Board, based on the available evidence and relevant publication ethics guidance.
The retraction process will follow the principles and recommendations outlined in the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Retraction Guidelines. A retraction notice will clearly identify the affected article and explain the reason for retraction. The original article will remain accessible where appropriate, but will be clearly marked as retracted to maintain the transparency of the scholarly record.
COPE Retraction Guidelines: https://publicationethics.org/guidance/guideline/retraction-guidelines





